Abolish the draft, and let these amateurs sign for what the market will bear. Then we can stop having these idiotic discussions about what’s wrong with the draft. The draft is just wrong, period.
I haven’t thought through all of the implications of such a thing in this day and age (given all of the changes to the baseball labor market, the example of the pre-draft system is probably of little utility), but as I sit here right now, I can’t see how it would create any more problems than any of the draft “solutions” people have suggested. Sure it’s radical, but only in immediate effect, not long term implications. At least I don’t think so, anyway.
David is throwing it out there for us. Let’s run with it. And please, try to think harder than “the Yankees would just buy all of the good players.” That doesn’t happen now with international signings, and they haven’t raised a big Tigers-with-Porcello ruckus in the amateur draft.
Educate me, people: what would be the pros and cons of just chucking this system and going all free-agent?