While I was staring at his stats, I noticed something. Aaron had a .374 career on-base percentage, but he never led the league in OBP. That seemed like an awfully high number never to have led the league, so I started looking, and that kind of spiraled, and I ended up with a list of the (modern) all-time and active players with the highest career ranking in a stat without ever having led the league.
This fun stuff is now presented to you. I’ll follow up with an article on pitchers in a week or two.
Neither of these guys is especially surprising. Jackson, of course, had his career cut short, and the only thing that stopped Votto last year was a knee injury. In his abbreviated career, Jackson never finished lower than eighth in the batting race. That second-place finish in 1911, when he hit .408, had to really hurt, but that’s what you get for playing in the same league as Ty Cobb. Votto has finished in the top five in batting each of the last four seasons.
From 1911 until 1926, Eddie Collins finished in the top 10 in OBP every year. But again, there was this guy Cobb and this other guy Babe Ruth. And, well, I’m sure you can see how it went. Berkman has suffered a similar fate. Plenty of high finishes, but during an offensive era, you really need to distinguish yourself to lead the league in something like OBP.
Slugging was the category that required me to travel farthest down the list for both career and active players. I’m not sure what to make of that except perhaps that sluggers slug. Both of these guys are, to an extent, products of the era. Guerrero slugged .664 in 2000 and only finished third behind a Coors-aided Todd Helton and Barry Bonds. Howard came close in 2006, but given his current decline, his career slugging percentage is likely headed down, and he won’t be leading the league anytime soon.
Hits: Eddie Collins – 3315 (9th), Bobby Abreu – 2437 (4th)
Collins shows up on our list for the second time. Abreu, as far as I can tell, is still looking for a job, but we’ll give him credit since he hasn’t given up looking. The answer for both is simple: walks. If you take a lot of walks, it’s hard to lead the league in hits.
Doubles: Barry Bonds – 601 (14th), Derek Jeter – 524 (3rd)
This is an interesting pairing. Perhaps the most hated living player with the most loved by any one city. Either way, these ranks are both the results of long careers. Neither Bonds nor Jeter ever has come especially close (Jeter has only one top-10 finish in doubles when he was fourth in 2004) to leading the league in this category.
I find triples really fascinating because of how much less common they are than they used to be, something that can be seen in the wide gap between our career leader and our active leader. Speaker’s 22 were just one off Sam Crawford‘s pace in 1913, but otherwise, he was a compiler much like Bonds and Jeter. Ichiro finished second in 2005 with 12 (Carl Crawford led this time, with 15), but he’s never had really notable triple totals.
Home runs: Rafael Palmiero 569 (12th), Jason Giambi – 429 (5th)
Here’s another interesting pairing. Palmeiro, among other things, is known as a good-never-great player, and his presence here confirms that as much as it confirms his presence in an era of inflated home run totals. In 1999, he did fall just one homer short (47 to Ken Griffey‘s 48) of leading the league. Giambi is, of course, a product of the same era. He’s just a little younger and hasn’t been given his walking papers quite yet.
Runs: Tris Speaker – 1882 (11th), Jim Thome – 1583 (3rd)
Speaker’s name is becoming common on this list, as he simply falls victim to playing at the same time as other great players. He managed three second-place finishes but was twice beaten out by Babe Ruth and once by our old friend Eddie Collins. Thome never has been really competitive in this category, but he has had a bunch of very good run-scoring seasons, and he’s played for a long time.
RBI: Willie Mays – 1903 (10th), Jim Thome – 1699 (2nd)
Am I really telling you that Willie-freaking-Mays never lead the league in RBI? Yes, yes I am. And talk about a fluke. He finished a second to legit star Duke Snider in 1955, but in1962 he finished second to, of all people, Tommy Davis, whose 153 RBI were a career high by, get this, 64. That’s right, his next-highest total was 89. Baseball is a funny game. Thome’s presence here (and the fact that he hasn’t been among the leaders very often) has to do with his checkered injury history.
Walks: Pete Rose – 1566 (14th), Bobby Abreu – 1456 (2nd)
Any time you can come up with a new statistical fact about Pete Rose—one he might not even have noted—it’s a little exciting. Rose, of course, was the ultimate compiler, and given that he played for about a million years, his presence isn’t surprising. Abreu is here by an accident of fate. In 2006, his 124 walks led all of baseball, but as he was traded from the NL to the AL midseason, he led neither league.
Stolen bases: Joe Morgan – 689 (11th), Bobby Abreu – 399 (7th)
Lou Brock, ever heard of him? Joe Morgan finished second to him in steals not once, not twice, but five different times. Then, later in his career, he finished second to Davey Lopes twice. Always a bridesmaid, never a bride. Still, I hear Morgan is doing just fine as a skilled analytical announcer. And yes, Abreu, again. He has a solid group of top-10 finishes, but he never managed to lead the league. I wonder how long it will take us to forget that Abreu was a really good player.