Is CarGo really that good?

Earlier this winter, The Hardball Times offered prospective fantasy baseball writers the opportunity to compete in a Hardball Times fantasy league. Entrants wrote fantasy baseball articles, the best of which would be chosen as our winner. While we could only choose one winner to play in the league (congratulations, Dave Chenok), we had so many great articles that we have decided to publish some of the best. This is the final one of those submissions.

Last season, Carlos Gonzalez delivered on the promise he showed in 2009, and led a lot of make-believe teams to championship glory. Fresh off a batting title and the major leagues’ only 30/20 season, CarGo (will be a popular first-round draft choice in 2011. If you managed to acquire him in a keeper league, you’re surely the envy of your competitors—but you may want to consider selling high.

Regardless of your league’s keeper rules and format, it is understandably difficult to give up on a 24-year-old center field-eligible player coming off a season that garnered him MVP consideration, even knowing the king’s ransom that many owners would gladly pay. There are several red flags surrounding Gonzalez’s breakout year, however.

First, consider the type of hitter Gonzalez is. There’s no disputing his ability to drive the ball or his speed on the basepaths, but his plate discipline leaves much to be desired. Gonzalez walked in only 6.3 percent of his plate appearances, and when you remove intentional passes, that figure drops to 5 percent, well below the 8 percent major league average. Only 14 players swung at more pitches outside the zone in 2010. Of the last 30 NL batting champions, only Freddy Sanchez had a lower spread between his batting average and on-base percentage than CarGo’s 40 points.

This free-swinging approach leaves Gonzalez vulnerable to poor luck on balls in play. His BABIP last season was .384, trailing only Austin Jackson and AL batting champ Josh Hamilton. Using Chris Dutton’s xBABIP calculator, Gonzalez’s figure “should” have settled in at around .350, reducing his .336/.376/.598 slash line to approximately .311/.352/.564*. While still a fantastic showing for a fantasy center fielder, a 60-point drop in OPS is nothing to sneeze at.

Of course, we know that hitters have a degree of control over their BABIP, especially those blessed with speed like CarGo’s. The possibility of him sustaining a mark that high exists, however remote it may be. But what about his career best marks in isolated power and homer-per-fly ball percentage? Addressing that concern is trickier. Gonzalez’s minor league numbers suggest that his power may be in line for regression, and HitTracker data would seem to support this conclusion: 13 of his 34 home runs were classified as “just enough.” However, keep in mind that at this stage of their careers, many hitters have experienced leaps in power that proved sustainable.

Aiding in the power process is Gonzalez’s home park, Coors Field. Its effect is well known, and all caveats about using home/road splits as an analytical tool aside, the results to this point cannot be ignored. Outside of Denver, Gonzalez has posted significantly less impressive, if still above-average, offensive numbers. The 386-point difference between his home and road OPS was by far the highest in baseball.

Is this paranoia? Is this nitpicking? Is this looking a gift horse in the mouth? The answer is probably yes to all three. But as Pablo Sandoval taught us yet again in 2010, there’s a dark and tragic side to any free swinger.

*difference in slugging percentage calculated by multiplying difference between actual and expected hits by total bases per hit in 2010, with home runs removed from both.

Print Friendly
 Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Google+0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone
« Previous: Card Corner: 1971 Topps: Chris Short
Next: Positional rankings redux »


  1. Treez said...


    I maybe wrong, but I believe he hasn’t even hit his ceiling quite yet. His free-swinging tendencies will diminish with more experience/at-bats in the tank.

    What is there not to like?
    Great glove, a huge threat on the base-paths, and his backyard being Coors Field. Granted, Coors helps him out, but this guy has the ability to park a couple out of the park any given plate appearance.

    btw, that 09’ Postseason performance is just a glimpse at what he can accomplish in his career, and YES, he did it against my Phils and LOST!

  2. Kyle said...


    I’m a big fan of CarGo as well, which is why I drafted him in every league I could last year. I remember telling people he’d eventually be as good as Holliday when they were traded for each other.

    That said, fantasy baseball is nothing if not nitpicking, particularly with keeper designations or a first-round pick. There are simply a ton of regression flags.

    CarGo is a hell of a ballplayer, that much nobody can dispute. The question is whether or not he’s a good bet to put up MVP-type numbers regularly, and that’s a lot less clear.

    Of course, I may just be feeling snakebitten after investing so heavily in Sandoval last season.

    And for the record, a couple of weeks ago, I traded CarGo in one of my leagues for Colby Rasmus and David Price, who come at a combined price tag only a few dollars more than CarGo’s keeper cost. Skittish CarGo owners should be looking for a similarly rich package.

  3. Brad Johnson said...

    I’m the commissioner of the league mentioned by Kyle. The reported deal made a lot of sense for Kyle’s roster and was one of those win-win moves for both clubs. Owners in a situation where they don’t need to cut payroll should look to bank a little more in return for Cargo.

  4. obsessivegiantscompulsive said...

    Sandoval taught us nothing in 2010 other than that ballplayers are human beings and when their personal life goes in the dumper – he went through divorce, custody battle over his daughter, and nearly losing his mother in the San Bruno blast – their performance can go in the dumper as well.

  5. Matt said...

    “Only 14 players swung at more pitches outside the zone in 2010. Of the last 30 NL batting champions, only Freddy Sanchez had a lower spread between his batting average and on-base percentage than CarGo’s 40 points”

    Yes it worrisome, but I think that will improve. To me though it just simply shows how sweet his swing is (talent). I will take talent anyday, see Vlad .320 career avg…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>