Card Corner: George Scottby Bruce Markusen
May 28, 2010
Admittedly, this is one of the more awkward looking cards in the otherwise striking set put out by Topps in 1980. Perhaps “clunky” would be a more fitting word than awkward. The airbrushing of New York Yankees colors and logos onto a picture of George Scott wearing a Boston Red Sox uniform is not exactly fine art at its best, but Topps can be forgiven for such slapdash work in an era that predated the wonders of “photo shop” on personal computers.
If you’re anything less than a diehard Yankees fan, you probably don’t even remember George “Boomer” Scott playing for the franchise. This is the only baseball card that shows him wearing Yankees pinstripes and colors, airbrushed or otherwise. Scott’s journey that landed him in New York happened only because his skills eroded during the late 1970s. Slowed by injuries and a lack of conditioning, the 34-year-old Scott began to decline in 1978. His play fell off the Green Monster precipice in 1979, prompting the Red Sox to trade him to the Kansas City Royals. Desperate for a power hitter, the Royals gave him a quick look, but concluded that Scott had lost his home run stroke and gave him his release.
Normally, a trade and a release during the same summer for an aging veteran spells the end of a career. Not so with Scott. The Yankees, at the tail end of an awful season, decided to audition Scott with the idea that he might be able to contribute in a platoon role in 1980. I distinctly remember Scott’s 1979 appearance in Yankees pinstripes as one of the few positive memories of an otherwise dismally tragic season; The Boomer batted .318 and slugged an even .500 in 44 late-season at-bats. Scott played so well that final month that both Topps and I thought the Yankees would bring him back for 1980. Yet, he became a victim of an offseason of rebuilding, which included signing another right-handed hitting first baseman-DH, Bob “The Bull” Watson.
Deciding that a Bull was more valuable than a Boomer, the Yankees let Scott become a free agent, making his Topps card null and void. The other 27 major league teams took a pass. Scott opted to continue his career in the Mexican League, hoping that another big league team might give him a call in the middle of the 1980 season. The call never came.
In retrospect, I wish the Yankees had brought Scott back for a longer look. I would have enjoyed seeing him finish his career with the ‘80 Yankees, a team managed brilliantly by the late, great Dick Howser. In his prime, Scott was a very good player, one of the elite right-handed power hitters of the 1970s. He was also a fun player, a slick, athletic first baseman whose agility belied his rounded build. Equally charming off the field, the giant-sized Scott entertained reporters with amusing answers to routine questions and an unusual brand of vocabulary. He was also a stylish dresser, both on and off the field.
An interesting wardrobe preference became a trademark of Scott’s pre-game activity. During his second stint with the Red Sox, Scott used to wear a rubberized suit in a futile attempt to lose some of the excess weight that always seemed to accumulate around his midsection. As former Sox manager Don Zimmer has noted, Scott sweated off a few pounds during each early evening workout, but he seemed to gain all the weight back by the time the first pitch was thrown.
Scott’s intriguing fashion choices continued during the game. Unlike most fielders, he wore a helmet while playing first base. Scott began wearing the helmet during his early Red Sox days, in reaction to some unruly fans on the road who had decided to hurl objects his way. Like his contemporary Dick Allen, and like John Olerud in future years, Scott put safety first when it came to playing first base.
But I’ll most remember Scott for this habit: He wore a distinctive necklace that appeared to be made of stones or ivory. When a reporter asked Scott to identify the material used to make the necklace he wore on the playing field, the first baseman responded dryly: “Second basemen’s teeth.” Actually, the necklace was made up of shells, wooded beads and possibly ivory tusks of some sort, but the reality never came close to matching the color of Scott’s sinister humor.
Scott also had an interesting way of inventing nicknames and catch phrases. He called his first baseman’s mitt, which was extremely dark in color, “Black Beauty.” He liked to call home runs “taters,” coining a phrase that Reggie Jackson and others would use in later years. Ron White would have been proud.
Given his colorful use of language, it’s no surprise that Boomer became a favorite of media members looking for a good quote. Forever smiling (as he is on his final Topps card), Scott also enjoyed talking to fans, developing a reputation for signing as many autographs as possible at American League ballparks.
At times, Scott’s outgoing personality overshadowed his ample abilities as a hitter. A key member of the 1967 “Impossible Dream” team, Scott remained a mostly productive player with the Red Sox through 1971 before being traded to the Milwaukee Brewers in a nine-player blockbuster deal that also involved notables like Tommy Harper and Jim Lonborg. As a member of the Brewers, Scott twice reached the 100-RBI mark and shared an American League home run crown in 1975 before returning to the Red Sox in 1976. He played productively for the Sox in ‘76 and ‘77 before his game began to fall off during the Red Sox’ summer swoon of ‘78.
After his playing days, Scott became a manager, first in the Mexican League and then most notably with an independent league team called the Massachusetts Mad Dogs. Filled with free spirits and wild personalities, the team reflected Scott’s loose and freewheeling managerial style. In 1996, the Mad Dogs won the North Atlantic League championship under Scott’s scattershot direction.
Scott is retired from managing today and battling some health problems caused by his continuing weight gain, which at one point put him well over the 400-pound mark. Last I heard, Boomer was trying to lose some of the weight and get himself in better condition to take a stab at managing again. I have no idea how good a minor league manager he would be, but I have to believe that baseball would be better off having a guy like George Scott back in the game.
Bruce Markusen is the author of seven books on baseball, including the award-winning A Baseball Dynasty: Charlie Finley’s Swingin’ A’s, the recipient of the Seymour Medal from the Society for American Baseball Research. He has also written The Team That Changed Baseball: Roberto Clemente and the 1971 Pittsburgh Pirates, Tales From The Mets Dugout, and The Orlando Cepeda Story.
Wasn’t there only 26 teams in 1979?
Posted 05/28 at 12:12 PM
Biig fan said...
Scott also had one of the worst seasons ever by a first basemen. Not sure I ever understood how that hapenned. See this article: <http://www.mlbexpertanalysis.com/blog/?p=170>
Posted 05/28 at 02:22 PM
Yes, there were 26 teams in 1979/80:
Remarkably, all of them have played in at least one World Series since; meanwhile, the Senators/Rangers (‘61), Expos/Nationals (‘69) and Mariners (‘77) have yet to make it to the final.
Posted 05/28 at 02:29 PM
Bruce Markusen said...
You are correct, gentlemen, about the number of teams! For some reason, I had added the Rockies and Marlins to my subconscious in 1979-80, even though they were years away from joining the major leagues.
Posted 05/28 at 11:42 PM
Dr. Memory said...
Bruce, it’s always a pleasure to see one of your little essays.
Posted 05/29 at 07:11 AM
Matt Tracy said...
Ha, second basemen’s teeth! Nice work Bruce. Hope to see you this summer!
Posted 05/29 at 11:34 AM
Northern Rebel said...
Thanks for this, Bruce!
As a Sawx fan, you are right up my alley!
Scott was a Kevin Youkilis type player, in that he was gold glove caliber, at both 3rd, and 1st base.
I fogot all about the taters name, until Bruce reminded me, and many of them were prodigious! He struck out too much, but played hard, with a smile on his face.
Yes, he endured a miserable 1968 season, hitting .171, with only 3 “taters,” in 350 AB’s.
Such was 1968.
Ray Oyler of Detroit hit .135. Mark Belanger hit .208 in 472 AB’s. Tom Tresh hit .195, in 507 AB’s! Even the mighty Rod Carew only checked in with a .273 Avg.
The league as a whole hit .230, which I believe remains a record low in major league history.
A lot of ballplayers who played in the 60’s, and early 70’s, had a batting average at least ten points lower than if they’d played in any other era. Carl Yastrzemski finished with a lifetime .286 avg. He surely was a better hitter than someone like Larry Walker, with his gaudy modern day stats.
The comparisons of hitters from different eras, (and pitchers) has always fascinated me, and I hope someone will help me delve into this realm in the future.
Meanwhile, God bless ya Boomer, stay healthy, and thanks for the memories!
Posted 05/29 at 04:37 PM
Biig fan said...
His bad year has nothing to do with comparing 1968 to other years, which is what you are doing. His OPS+ in 1968 (which compares him to other players playing in 1968) was 39. This is a HISTORICALLY bad season (I think the worst of any first basemen ever) and for a guy coming off two good seasons and about to have another bunch of good ones, I don’t understand it.
Posted 05/29 at 10:26 PM
Northern Rebel said...
It is quite an anomaly, considering the seasons that surrounded it. I wonder what he has to say about it. I’m not suggesting that outside stimuli was the only problem.
However I doubt this would have happened in 1970, or ‘75, or any other season besides 1968. I have to think that the pitching dominance that produced the lowest Batting average title in history, had some effect.
Posted 06/01 at 02:15 PM
Northern Rebel said...
Another extraordinary fact in the circumstances of Boomer’s nightmare year:
He won the Gold Glove that year!
Posted 06/01 at 02:27 PM
Robert Slaney said...
I believe The Red Sox Traded Scott to K.C. for Tom Poquette, Mid-June, 1979, the same day they traded Pete Ladd and Bobby Sprowl to Houston for Bob Watson who was also replacing Scott this time. I could never figure out why Scott never got a job in the Major Leagues(Blackballed?). He would have been a natural for the Sox as a minor league instructor. The best defensive first baseman I’ve ever seen(Been following the Sox since 1964)
Posted 06/02 at 03:28 PM
Northern Rebel said...
Correctamundo, Mr. Slaney!
I seem to remember Scott in an interview, or documentary saying he was blackballed, though for reasons never fully explained.
I’ve been a fan almost as long as you Bob, and there were only a handful I would put in his class. Mattingly, Keith hernandez, Yaz himself, Vic Power, and Wes Parker are a few who come to mind.
Another underrated 1st baseman, (for obvious reasons) was Bill Buckner. He broke an assists record that had stood for decades, that he may still hold.
Posted 06/02 at 04:11 PM
Page 1 of 1
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.
Next Article: The virtual 1962-69 Cincinnati Reds (Part 2)>> <<Previous Article: The college board