February 9, 2010
Order Now Get "The world champ of baseball annuals." The Hardball Times Baseball Annual 2010 features articles by THT's staff as well as Bill James, Tom Tango and Craig Wright and contains much, much more. Please support THT and use this link to purchase the Annual.  Get the fantasy book that everyone's raving about! Edited by THT Fantasy's Rob McQuown and Michael Street, and featuring our own Matt Hagen on prospects. Shipping now from ACTA! 
Pat Andriola
Rich Barbieri John Barten Brian Borawski Craig Brown Evan Brunell Chuck Brownson Kevin Dame Joshua Fisher David Gassko Jeremy Greenhouse Brandon Isleib Chris Jaffe Max Marchi Bruce Markusen Dan Novick Harry Pavlidis Alex Pedicini Jeff Sackmann Nick Steiner Dave Studeman Steve Treder Bryan Tsao Tuck! Geoff Young John Brattain And here's the full roster.
Or you can search by:
Gear up for baseball season with Chicago White Sox tickets and New York Yankees tickets. LA Angels tickets, Houston Astros tickets, and Atlanta Braves tickets are hot sellers! You can get Boston Red Sox tickets, San Diego Padres tickets or Chicago Cubs tickets for your favorite baseball fan. Coast to Coast Tickets has the best MLB tickets like Minnesota Twins tickets, LA Dodgers tickets, Milwaukee Brewers tickets, New York Met tickets and St. Louis Cardinals tickets. Find premium Chicago Cubs tickets and other Chicago tickets at JustGreatTickets.com. Chicago Cubs Tickets Chicago Tickets  All content on this site (including text, graphs, and any other original works), unless otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons License. |
Does this conversion thing work? Joakim Soria (Part 2)by Harry PavlidisApril 28, 2009 Sean "Rally" Smith has updated his Baseball Projections web site with a brand new feature—historical pitching Wins Above Replacement (WAR). This made my plans to integrate park factors and leverage values into my Retrosheet database a slightly lower priority. Back to the topic at hand.... Should the Royals convert Joakim Soria into a starting pitcher?Last week, I explored the pre-MLB history and PITCHf/x data that are available on Soria. Given his experience and repertoire, it seems like a valid point to ponder—would Soria and the Royals benefit by moving him to their rotation? There are a lot of angles in play here, from Soria's health (he's shelved for a few days due to shoulder soreness) to the other moves necessitated (move one starter somewhere and shuffle the bullpen) and even the "chemistry" component. In today's game, how much of an edge would be lost by removing a proven and reliable closer from his role? So, I don't think I can answer the question as stated—hence the title of this article. Does this thing work?While we all can think of teams converting a closer to a starter, I was a little surprised by how rarely something like that happens. Plenty of pitchers break in as a relievers and become starters, but the closer to starter conversion is fairly uncommon. To find comps for the hypothetical swap of Soria, I hit the Retrosheet database with a query (complete code below) to find pitchers who had at least 10 saves in 50 games, and fewer than five starts, in "year 1" and had at least 10 appearances in "year 2" where they made at least nine more starts than relief appearances. In other words, to qualify with one relief appearance, you needed 10 or more starts. Twenty relief appearances, and you'll need 29 starts to go with them to qualify. The cut-offs are arbitrary; you can play with them on your own if you so choose. Data covers the Retrosheet era, 1953 onward. Based on the parameters selected, I ended up with 16 pitchers:
Now, it isn't fair to base this comparison on just these two seasons. Each player has some history coming in and some future history to make going out. Well, almost each player. Key was a rookie in "year 1", Dempster and Myers are just now living their post-"year 2" future and Soria hasn't even had "year 2." Let's compare the before and after phases for each of our 16 comps, plus Soria. in terms of games started. Click any of the charts below for a larger version  * rookie in "year 1," no "before" ** "year 2" was 2008, no "after" *** no "year 2," no "after" Aguilera had experience as a starter and a reliever before entering his "year 1." After one season as a pure starter, he moved back to the bullpen for good. Batista and Bell had similar usage patterns, mostly sticking as a starter after the switch. Chacon went from starter to reliever abruptly, but from "year 2" on he played both roles. Dempster had a long record as a starter before the Cubs made him their closer. He seems settled back into the middle of the rotation role now. Garrelts and Gossage both had minimal experience as starters before becoming relievers and then starters in earnest. Garrelts stayed in the starting role, Gossage went back to the bullpen. I think that worked out all right for the Goose. Graves had one year as a starter, aside from a few starts in "year 1." Key barely makes the list, with 10 saves as a rookie. He rarely made relief appearances beyond that first season. Lefferts had made some starts about a decade before he went from a reliable 20-save guy to the rotation. It didn't last; he finished his career in the bullpen. Lowe has made the switch to starter very well, judging by his ground ball rates and paycheck. Myers lasted one year in relief. It's too soon to know if that's forever, but it seems that he'll be a starter for the foreseeable future. Shaw barely qualified, with 11 saves, and spent most of his career, before and after, as a starter. Smoltz had a long career as a starter, a short one as a closer, and another short one as a starter. The latter remains in progress, however. Swift's time in the bullpen was brief; he earned more starts as his career progressed. Wood, not Kerry, made an impressive leap (see below) and never looked back. The numbers This shows WAR during both of the sample years, and you'll see that Gossage was an amazing reliever and Wood was a brilliant starter.  Now the difference from "year 1" to "year 2," with positive numbers indicating an improvement.  For the most part, the moves worked out well for the teams. The average gain was 2.2 wins, with winners beating losers 11-3 (Myers was a wash). But look closely, and you'll see only two pitchers had a "year 1" WAR better than Soria's: Gossage, who cost his team a few wins by moving to the rotation, and Swift who barely improved, in terms of WAR, as a starter. Swift also had more experience in the major leagues as a starter. Don't do itNot often does a successful reliever become a successful starter. Soria has a history—and a present—of arm problems. His best pitch, in terms of throwing strikes, is a fastball that doesn't average over 92 mph in short spurts. Drop him a couple mph to imagine him starting. Throwing high-80s without secondary pitches that can find the zone could be a deadly combination. It's just my opinion, there's no definitive answer, but I'd have Soria drop one of his pitches and stay in the bullpen. It probably will be easier for him to throw strikes by keeping fewer pitches sharper. References and Resources Comp Filter: selectWAR Data Harry Pavlidis admits he has a baseball problem. He also writes for Beyond the Boxscore, Out of the Ivy and his own blog, Cubs f/x. Feedback, questions and comments are appreciated - harrypav@gmail.com Commenting is not available in this weblog entry. Do you have a general question or comment for one of THT's writers? Send it in to our weekly mailbag We also welcome unsolicited op-ed pieces of approximately 500 words for consideration. We reserve the right to edit for length, clarity and consistency of style. Please include your whole name and location to be considered. If you have a comment about this specific article, please email the writer. Next Article: Backstopping and roaming wide (Part 1: 1890-1935)>> <<Previous Article: THT Daily: The other park effect | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
