February 9, 2010

Fangraphs Player Search:

Order Now


Get "The world champ of baseball annuals." The Hardball Times Baseball Annual 2010 features articles by THT's staff as well as Bill James, Tom Tango and Craig Wright and contains much, much more. Please support THT and use this link to purchase the Annual.


Get the fantasy book that everyone's raving about! Edited by THT Fantasy's Rob McQuown and Michael Street, and featuring our own Matt Hagen on prospects. Shipping now from ACTA!


And here's the full roster.



Or you can search by:

Sports Tickets

Gear up for baseball season with Chicago White Sox tickets and New York Yankees tickets. LA Angels tickets, Houston Astros tickets, and Atlanta Braves tickets are hot sellers! You can get Boston Red Sox tickets, San Diego Padres tickets or Chicago Cubs tickets for your favorite baseball fan. Coast to Coast Tickets has the best MLB tickets like Minnesota Twins tickets, LA Dodgers tickets, Milwaukee Brewers tickets, New York Met tickets and St. Louis Cardinals tickets.
Find premium Chicago Cubs tickets and other Chicago tickets at JustGreatTickets.com.
Chicago Cubs Tickets
Chicago Tickets
Championship Tickets



Creative Commons License
All content on this site (including text, graphs, and any other original works), unless otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

The two sides of the Cubs Rule 5 coin

by Harry Pavlidis
April 15, 2009

2009 may be remembered as the year Jim Hendry lost patience. The Chicago Cubs are coming off a 97-win season with a new look at many levels.

Felix Pie, Rich Hill and Ronny Cedeño failed to meet expectations, ran out of options and were traded to new teams. Michael Wuertz, who often rode the Iowa-to-Chicago shuttle, was shipped to Oakland. Former first-round draft choices Ryan Harvey and Mark Pawelek were released. Tyler Colvin is nervous. Dog house resident Chad Gaudin was released, which cost the Cubs $1.6 million.

Let's not forget about Donald Veal. Marked as the Cubs' best left-handed pitching prospect, Veal dealt with the deaths of both his parents as a minor leaguer while struggling to meet the organization's expectations. When the Rule 5 Draft came along after the 2008 season, Donnie was left exposed and picked up by the Pirates. No one knew for sure if he'd stick in Pittsburgh, and I thought it was quite likely he'd end up being returned before Opening Day.

Somewhat lost in the news of Veal's departure was another Cubs/Reds Rule 5 draft and trade. Having picked Josh Hamilton from the Rays in 2006 and selling him off to Cincinnati (which later dealt him to Texas), the Cubs reversed the flow in 2008. The Reds selected David Patton from the Rockies and sold him to the Cubs. Since Rule 5 still confuses me, I was expecting Patton to end up somewhere other than Chicago—whether it be Colorado or Cincinnati.

Well, what I expected has not happened. Donald Veal is working out of the Pirates' bullpen and David Patton out of the Cubs'. Nothing is guaranteed—either player could end up being returned at some point. (Toronto gave Randy Wells one inning in 2008 before returning him to the Cubs.)

Both Patton and Veal have made just one appearance to date; let's take a look via PITCHf/x.

Pitching Profiles

I'll start with Veal, the lefty. His reputation coming up was pretty simple—hard thrower with a plus curve. In just 28 pitches in the majors, he did indeed show those two attributes to some extent. Unfortunately, Veal Attribute No. 3 was also on display: erratic command.

Veal's fastball appears to be a four-seamer, but with a little more tail than most. In his only outing, it sat comfortably around 92-93 mph. His curveball isn't a big yakker, and Veal throws it in the mid-to-upper 70s. He also mixed in a pair of change-ups, which were a nice 7-8 mph slower than the heat.

About that command...perhaps it isn't erratic. Perhaps it is consistently poor? I know, one game is just one game, but the man's reputation does precede him.

image

This is from the catcher's view (you can click for a larger version) and shows the typical southpaw's bottom-left to top-right dispersion of pitches. Thing is, bottom-left is below the ground and top-right is the middle of the plate. I'm all for guys working down and away, but Veal's fastball, which should be tailing to the catcher's right, was missing left by a foot (on more than one occasion). The results are aggregate flight paths like these:

image

David Patton had a lot more success than Veal. His only outing as a Cub lasted two innings, and he started off by allowing a home run to Hunter Pence. Patton set the next six down easily. I've gone into some more detail on Patton at Cubs f/x, but you'll only find the flight paths here.

Patton, like Veal, works low and away. In Patton's debut, however, he threw strikes with both of his pitches—a four-seamer that seems to run less than Veals, but at about the same speed, and a slurvey looking slider that gave hitters fits.

image

Patton's control wasn't perfect, but certainly not wild as Veal. His two pitch flight paths look more reasonable:

image

What's next?

The data on Patton come from his first game above Single-A. That seems to place the odds of sticking squarely against him, despite the quality of his stuff. He's made it this far, and the Cubs are taking the long view. To date, he's been used sparingly, so I'm anxious to see his next outing.

The same applies to Veal, who hasn't climbed the bump since his debut. Veal has played at higher levels than Patton, but with a mixed record. His lone performance as a Pirate was consistent with his reputation, which may be unfortunate. The Pirates lack pitching depth, so Veal has a good chance to stick and grow into a LOOGY role.

References and Resources
PITCHf/x data provided by MLBAM. Pitch IDs by the author.

Harry Pavlidis admits he has a baseball problem. He also writes for Beyond the Boxscore, Out of the Ivy and his own blog, Cubs f/x. Feedback, questions and comments are appreciated - harrypav@gmail.com




Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

Do you have a general question or comment for one of THT's writers? Send it in to our weekly mailbag We also welcome unsolicited op-ed pieces of approximately 500 words for consideration. We reserve the right to edit for length, clarity and consistency of style. Please include your whole name and location to be considered. If you have a comment about this specific article, please email the writer.



The best online source for major league baseball tickets is Ticket City.

     Next Article:  The cult of the sure thing>> <<Previous Article:  THT Daily: Break up the Mariners