Overrated for 2009

In this following article, I’m going to be looking at a few players who I think will be overrated in 2009. However, the whole concept of overrated and underrated depends a lot on your league construct. For example, if you’re playing with friends from your hometown, players from your area may be valued more highly than normal. Thus, the following article will look at overrated players in general.

Ian Kinsler, 2B, Texas: Kinsler clearly has a great skill set with strong power and speed skills while playing a premium position. However, remember that Kinsler is still a guy who has yet to put together a full season worth of at bats. Kinsler has been around a late first round pick in most drafts I’ve seen. I think Kinsler just has too much risk to invest a first round pick in.

Evan Longoria, 3B, Tampa Bay: Longoria was very good in his major league debut last season and showcased some serious power skills. However, he’s a guy who has still only played in one major league season, meaning there’s less reliability with his projection. Additionally, there is some batting average downside with Longoria. With the risk he brings, I would make lean towards a guy like Aramis Ramirez over Longoria, even though Longoria might provide some additional upside.

Cole Hamels, SP, Philadelphia: Hamels has a tremendous skill set, one of the best in the game. However, he will be coming off a innings increase (don’t forget the postseason innings he pitched). He definitely has the skill and talent of a starter who should be picked in the top three or four rounds. But is Hamels’ injury risk something you want to take on that early?

Chris Davis, 1B/3B, Texas: I took a more in depth look at Davis in a past article. A lot of people will be tempted by Davis’ power potential. However, like the guys mentioned before him, Davis carries quite a bit of risk. With the spots he has gone in in recent mock draft, I would try to avoid Davis. You can get power elsewhere without taking as much risk.

Carlos Zambrano, SP, Chicago (NL): Zambrano showed signs of his past workload catching up with him last year, and the injury risk with him still remains. He has another big warning flag with his declining strikeout rate over the last few years. All in all, Zambrano is guy whose skill set is not that impressive. When you combine this with his injury risk, Zambrano is a player who carries a lot of downside risk.

Daisuke Matsuzaka, SP, Boston: On the surface, Matsuzaka had an excellent year last year with an 18-3 record and a sparkling 2.90 ERA. However, his skills really declined as his walk rate shot up and his strikeout rate went down. Overall, the skill set he has displayed over his first two major league seasons has not been that impressive. Many people have noted that Matsuzaka’s approach last year was to try and avoid hard contact, which would help explain why he had such a low BABIP. However, it’s really easy to fit a story to a past event. I wouldn’t want to take the risk that would be involved with finding if Matsuzaka has a unique skill to help control his BABIP.

Jermaine Dye, OF, Chicago (AL): Dye has been pretty durable during his stay with the White Sox. In fact, he has been fairly durable for the last five years. However, Dye will be entering his age-35 season next year and his risk of collapse and injury only continue to climb as he gets older. You should be able to get a player with a little more upside and less risk, maybe someone like Andre Ethier, at a similar position as Dye.

Print Friendly
 Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Google+0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone
« Previous: The double-unlucky pitching staff
Next: Today at THT »


  1. jon said...

    This article would be better if there were less opinion and more analysis on the “overrating” of the players.

  2. Phil said...

    Can’t disagree with any of the guys you mentioned.  Good list, could also include IMO BJ Upton, Josh Hamilton, Derrek Lee, right off the top of my head

  3. Greg Roberts said...

    It doesn’t seem Dye fits on this list. A long established veteran with a fairly predictable level of output. I am not sure who is overrating Dye to be honest. I am pretty sure people are expecting pretty well what he will provide.

    To be honest I think Matsuzaka and Zambrano are very good entries as they both have good surface stats and weak underlying skills essentially. Kinsler, Hamels and Longoria are all young with tremendous skills and you are merely speculating that they are too young or likely to get injured. A game that you probably don’t want to play.

  4. Corey Dawkins said...

    I agree with everyone you mentioned above.  Also another one that I think is always over valued in fantasy is Joe Mauer.  In real life, he is exactly the type of catcher you want.  Fantasy wise though, he doesn’t excel at any stat except OBP compared to his peers.  I think you could easily grab Doumit or someone else much later in the draft and get much better value.

  5. Nevin said...

    Agree with the tack and most of the choices.  Don’t, though, agree that Andre Ethier has more upside than Dye.  As a 26 year old, Dye put up a .321/.390/.561 line in KC with 33 HR, 41 doubles, 118 RBIs.  At 34, he’s turned into a guy you can expect to hit around 30-ish HRs, and his upside is 38+.

    Ethier, meanwhile, at 26 last year set career marks with .305/.375/.510, 20 HR, 38 2Bs.  His upside would seem to be more in the 30-ish HR area that you can more reliably count on from Dye.

    Seems like you’re talking about upside in value, rather than upside in performance, I guess, which isn’t really clear (to me) from the way you’ve written it.

  6. Will said...

    Looking for advice.  It sounds like I’m overrating Kinsler.  I’ve got him at #10 on my list.

    Behind him are guys like Utley (not sure what to make of his health/power), OF’s like Hamilton, Holliday and 1B’s like Teixeira (too hard to spell) and Ryan Howard(BA drag) and Berkman.

    I’m leary of pitchers (Santana sounds like a health risk) and Lincecum’s great, but…pitcher’s just seem too risky.

    My (perhaps flawed)  Top Ten:
    1. H. Ramirez
    2. J. Reyes
    3. A. Pujols
    4. D. Wright
    5. ARod (suspension coming???)
    6. R. Braun
    7. G. Sizemore
    8. M. Cabrera
    9. J. Rollins
    10. I. Kinsler

    Who should I be looking at in spots 10-12, if not Ian Kinsler?

  7. bpasinko said...

    Latest is Utley may be ready for opening day, in that case and even not, I’d rank him higher than Kinsler.

    Other than that I’m not sure, I’ve faced your problem in many a mock draft this year.  I’d certainly rather have Kinsler than Josh Hamilton or even some 1b that I’ve seen go in those 10-15 spots.  Is this wrong?

  8. John DiFool said...

    Longoria would be on my list of guys likely to develop into superstars-he has no business being on this one (nor does the elder Upton, only 24, Justin even more so).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>