The Verdict: Houston, we have a problem.

As we all know, the Houston Astros are now members of the American League West after spending their first 50 years in the National League. Houston transitions to the AL to create two 15-team leagues with three divisions of five teams each. They are the first franchise to switch leagues since the Milwaukee Brewers moved to the National League over 15 years ago.

Despite the Astros being one of the worst teams in baseball and having a limited number of relevant fantasy baseball options, their move will have an impact on fantasy leagues.

Because there are two 15-team leagues, there now must be interleague games every day of the season. This means that each team will play 20 more interleague games throughout the season, not just during two specific periods, as we have been accustomed to since 1997. This will have a profound impact on fantasy teams that rely on designated hitters who will potentially lose at-bats due to more games being played in National League parks.

In addition, NL Central pitchers will not get the benefit of facing the Astros, a poor team destined for more than 100 losses, several times during the year. On the other hand, AL West pitchers now reap the benefits of having Houston in their division.

There’s an even more important issue in fantasy leagues arising from Houston’s move to the AL. This has a direct impact on AL or NL-only leagues. NL-only leagues now lose an entire team’s worth of players and minor leaguers. Granted, second baseman Jose Altuve is probably the only Astro worth drafting in many formats. But plenty of deeper leagues would necessitate going further into the Astros’ organization for fantasy help, including players such as Bud Norris, Carlos Pena, Justin Maxwell, Jose Veras, Lucas Harrell, Brett Wallace, Fernando Martinez, or Jason Castro. Now these players are off-limits to NL-only leagues and all of a sudden available for AL-only leagues.

Taking this a step further, AL or NL-only keeper leagues have a dilemma on their hands. If a team in an NL-only keeper league had Altuve, chances are he would be kept since the pool for second baseman is relatively thin. Now that team will lose its second baseman because the Astros are in the American League. Fantasy commissioners need to come up with a plan to handle the transition. While we have known about this for quite some time, we cannot expect all fantasy league commissioners to have implemented a process for dealing with this situation. Now is the time to act before drafts take place.

One option is to offer a one-year extension or grace period where NL-only teams can better prepare for losing a player such as Altuve, or even minor leaguers in dynasty leagues. This would allow everyone an opportunity to set themselves up for the future without being unduly prejudiced because of the move by maintaining ownership of Astro players knowing they will be lost at the end of the 2013 season. Or you could set up some sort of arrangement that would allow trades with other AL-only teams to even things out.

There is more than one way to handle this unique situation, and they are all equally meritorious. But whichever one is selected, fantasy league commissioners need to have the answers immediately. All league members should know how to proceed if the Houston transition directly affects their league. As long as the commissioner is specific, expeditious and rational in his decision-making, then the league can smoothly handle any questions or issues that may arise.

Print Friendly
« Previous: Searching for home field advantage with PITCHf/x
Next: Five questions: Kansas City Royals »

Comments

  1. John Dillinger said...

    The time to address whether some or all Astros should be grandfathered in NL keeper leagues was this time last year.  Also, it may be unrealistic to expect Altuve to steal many bases when they find themselves behind 6-1 in the third, which could be a frequent occurrence

  2. Homer Simpson said...

    Bud Selig’s plan is finally complete.  His Brewers are finally cemented into the NL.  What a douche.

  3. Brad Johnson said...

    I don’t see why this scenario is any different than say, the Blue Jays trading D’Arnaud to the Mets. It’s a unique, one-off event that is akin to a couple interesting players suffering season ending injuries. I presume there is no compensation plan if my ace keeper requires TJS between now and draft day?

  4. BensBias said...

    This issue came up in a keeper NL only league I am in and it was decided last year that we could not keep any Astros for 2013. The move to the AL hurt owners of Altuve, etc. but rather than be left with nothing they were able to get something of value for them.

  5. salvo said...

    I’m pretty sure that each team does NOT have 20 more inter-league games than before.

    Yeah, the Cardinals, whom I assume are typical, play a total of 20 interleague games in 2013, vs. the AL West teams and four games with KC.

  6. George said...

    As a practical matter for our 12-team NL league the software we use (CBS) simply could not handle an “NL+ Astros” format (or at least could not in the winter when we figured out what we were going to do).  Without the Astros, 12-team NL (23 positions) is incredibly thin talentwise.  We debated two options:

    1) Cut a pitching slot and combine MI and CI into an infielder slot
    2) Go AL/NL

    Ended up doing number 2 and thus ended an NL-Roto league going back 22 years.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current day month ye@r *