Top 10 least likely cycles in history

You have to admit, it sounded liked a joke when you first heard the news.

On July 16, 2010, a new baseball hitter rapped out his first career cycle. This feat, approximately as rare for hitters as a no-hitter is for pitchers, requires a batter to single, double, triple and homer in one game.

So it was with great surprise that the sporting world learned that the newest member of this exclusive club was Giants catcher Bengie Molina.

Bengie Molina?

image
Molina, in action.

See? Told you it sounded like a joke. When you think cycle hitters, you don’t think Bengie Molina. A cycle requires some speed and Molina is a catcher, the slowest of all positions. Even worse, he’s an aging past-his-prime one. And he, well, let’s just say he’s not the most athletic looking player out there, either. Yet sure enough he hit the cycle with what is his sixth triple enabled him to join the cycle club.

That brings up some questions: Was this the most unlikely cycle ever, and most importantly what are the most unlikely cycles ever?

Plan of action

I have a simple system to figure this out. First, take a player’s singles, doubles, triples and homers hit, and divide all by plate appearances. Using PA works better than AB. Ultimately, a player who draws a ton of walks should have a harder time hitting for the cycle because more walks make four hits in a game less likely.

At any rate, once you’ve divided 1B, 2B, 3B and HR by PA, multiply the four results together for the final score. Wait – multiply? Why not add? Basic algebra: 1B/PA plus 2B/PA plus 3B/PA plus HR/PA is the same thing as H/PA, and I’m not looking for the best hitters. A player who hits .350 with no power would score great by that method because he has a nice H/PA. Multiplying rewards those who best balanced and punishes those badly imbalanced, and I’m looking for least-balanced guys to make my bottom 10.

Finally, I want to look at the stats in the cycle season, not career stats, because skills can change over time, most obviously in terms of speed, but power and ability to get hits also go down as well. This isn’t perfect. For example, when you use only single-season scores, the most likely cycle hitter ever was Gary Ward with the 1980 Twins.

Huh? He only had 46 PA that year – but he hit 10 singles, six doubles, two triples and a dinger in that span. It’s a sample size quirk, but this problem is less problematic than the one caused by using career stats.

Without further delay, here are the 10 least likely cycles

10. Chris Speier, 1978 Expos, 570 PA, 100 singles, 18 doubles, three triples, five homers.

A lot of guys have hit for the cycle with a worse batting average than the .251 mark Speier posted in 1978, but they aren’t so heavily dependent on singles. Speier’s Isolated Power of .078 is the sixth-worst by any cycle hitter. His slugging average (.329) is “only” eighth worst.

Speier has got to be the least likely man to ever hit for two cycles. His other one came in 1988, despite a season batting average of .216, which is tied fourth worst among the nearly 300 cycle hitters.

image
Chris Speier: two-timer cycler turned bench coach

This is a bit of a tangent, by Speier’s main competition for least likely to hit multiple cycles is John Olerud. Though Olerud was a fine hitter, he had one memorable feature in his pair of cycles. Each time it was his only triple of the year. There are only 16 cycles by batters who hit no other triple all season long, but Olerud has two of them. Bizarre.

9. Charlie Moore, 1980 Brewers: 356 PA, 76 singles, 13 doubles, two triples, two homers

I’m a little surprised to see Moore on this list. The longtime Milwaukee backstop was actually having a good year hitting the ball, as his .291 batting average attests. Plus he hardly drew any walks (24 in 111 games).

Like Speier, his problem was power. He actually had less power than Speier, as his woeful .072 ISO attests. Somehow, a man who averaged an extra base hit once every 21 PA on the year belted out three in one game, though.

8. John Mayberry, 1977 Royals: 641 PA, 79 singles, 22 doubles, one triple, 23 homers.

Mayberry is a different creature from Speier and Moore. Power was never his problem. He just couldn’t make contact. He only hit .230 on the year. Between his bad batting average and his ability to draw walks (83), he couldn’t quite manage to average a single every other game.

The complete lack of speed also hurt him. His career high was three triples in a season, and that was five years before he hit for the cycle.

Of the 21 times a person hit for the cycle with only one triple, Mayberry had the second most plate appearances on the year. Just above Mayberry in first place is Olerud, who had 679 PA in his 2001 cycle season. Just below Mayberry in third place is Olerud, with 630 PA in his other cycle season, 1997. Weird hitter, that Olerud.

image
John Olerud: king of the well-timed triple.

7. Bengie Molina, 2010 Giants/Rangers: 333 PA, 59 singles, nine doubles, one triple, five homers. (All numbers prior to Friday).

Here’s the man who inspired the list. Even if you ignore the sole triple, his numbers are pretty bad across the line.

His numbers should change as the year goes on, further worsening his score. I can’t imagine he’ll hit another triple this year, but he’ll never end up on “top” of this list. Then again, comparing his scores to Charlie Moore, I don’t see anyway out of the bottom 10 for Molina.

Here’s a random fact: though he’s only hit six triples in his 13-year career, four have come in the last five seasons. He went five years without a triple in the middle of his career but has since averaged almost one per year. Who knew he had it in him?

image
The look of a triples hitter.

6. Cesar Tovar, 1972 Twins: 548 PA, 117 singles, 20 doubles, six triples, two homers.

I’m surprised he scores worse than Molina. Going component by component, he seems to do better than the current catcher. He scores better in singles, doubles and triples, but Molina’s advantage comes from homers, especially when adjusted for playing time. It’s pretty close, but these guys are all packed in tightly. The real separation begins as we move along into the top three.

Tovar was a good player for a while, but his batting average dropped 50 points in 1972, and he never had that much power. It would’ve made a lot more sense for him to hit the cycle in 1970, when he led the league in doubles and triples while hitting .300 with 10 homers. That’s not how it worked out, though.

5. Chad Moeller, 2004 Brewers: 349 PA, 47 singles, 13 doubles, one triple, five homers.

Moeller is a pretty good comp for Molina. Both are contemporary catchers. In fact, they were only born seven month apart. Both have almost the exact number of plate appearances in their cycle seasons (for now, Molina should move up obviously). Each had one triple and five homers.

Moeller’s advantage comes in doubles, but it’s not enough to offset his big disadvantage: an overall complete inability to frickin’ hit! Molina hit .208 that year, which is not only over 30 points below Molina’s current mark, but is the third worst batting average in the history of baseball’s cycle club.

image
Moeller, last year, not hitting a triple.

Rather interestingly, Moeller’s .208 average isn’t the worst by a Milwaukee Brewers batter. The second worst batting average by a cycle hitter is Jody Gerut, who hit .197 this year – but still managed to hit a cycle for the Brewers. Normally I’d say Gerut’s average could go up as the season goes along, but Milwaukee cut him. Given how bad he was this year (and prior to 2010), Moeller should end the year with his .197 average.

The worst batting average by any cycle hitter is .173, by Andjuar Cedeno in 1992. He also had the worst slugging average in the entire club (.277), and the worst 1B/PA ratio. Despite that, Cedeno doesn’t make this overall bottom 10. It’s a tough crowd to beat out when you get this low. He hit “only” the 14th least-likely cycle of all-time by my system. Thank God for that 35th-worst isolated power!

4. Tim Foli, 1976 Expos: 546 PA, 101 singles, 36 doubles, one triple, six homers.

What was it with 1970s Expos shortstops? First Speier, who manned the position for the club in the latter half of the 1970s, comes in tenth place on this list, and now Foli, who played short in Quebec prior to Speier, appears on this list.

Fun fact: the Expos traded Chris Speier straight up to San Francisco for Tim Foli in April 1977. Based on this list, it was a fairly even trade.

I’m surprised to see Foli score so poorly. He easily has the best doubles-power on the list, and among this bottom ten only Charlie Moore can top Foli’s .264 batting average. Also, his one triple and six homers aren’t good, but look typical for this crowd.

One triple and six homers are typical, but most of those guys are doing it in 300-some PA, not Foli’s 546. In fact, if you ignore singles and doubles for a second and just multiply the 3B/PA and HR/PA score for all cycle hitters, Tim Foli comes in last out of the 294 contenders.

image
Decades later, Foli still doesn’t look like he knows how he hit for the cycle.

3. Otis Clymer, 1908 Senators: 397 PA, 77 singles, 11 doubles, four triples, one homer.

Yeah, I never heard of him either. Incredibly, he had an OPS+ of 103 that year, which just goes to show just how putrid offense was in 1908, the low point of the Deadball Era. Should I make an era adjustment? No way – batters in low-scoring eras are less likely to hit for the cycle.

Clymer is Tim Foli without the doubles. Sure, his combined 3B/HR score is better, but the most notable difference was Clymer hitting one-third as many doubles (albeit in only two-thirds the PA) as Foli.

Clymer is one of only four men with only one homer in their cycle season. Only one had more PA than Clymer, Lon Knight (whoever he was), in 1883. Aside from Clymer, there’s only one time since 1900 a batter’s only HR of the year came in his cycle game: Gary Ward in his 46 PA “season” in 1980. (The fourth was was Abner Dalrymple in 1891.)

Clymer actually played right field. While shortstops and catchers dominate this list, there are some rightfielders (Clymer and Tovar), and one first baseman (Mayberry).

2. Ivan DeJesus, 1980 Cubs: 692 PA, 128 singles, 26 doubles, three triples, three homers.

This is the second one to make it from 1980, making that the only year with multiple representatives. Another four came in the 1970s, so 1972-80 was the golden era for unlikely cycles.

Remember how I noted if you looked only at triples and homers Tim Foli scores the worst overall? DeJesus is runner up. It makes sense looking at the numbers – he averaged a triple or homer once every month. Yet he got one of each in one game.

DeJesus didn’t have Foli’s double power. As a result, DeJesus has the third-worst ISO in the history of cycle hitters: .066. Second worst is Clymer. The worst ISO is also the least likely cycle hitter of all.

image
DeJesus: the least likely cycler in memory

1. Bill Collins, 1910 Braves: 656 PA, 125 singles, six doubles, seven triples, three homers.

Those are some pretty dang impressive power numbers Collins has there. Not many guys average less than one double per 100 trips to the plate. Even back in 1900 that was true. And he was only slightly better with triples not nearly as effective with homers.

Added bonus: He did it while playing left field. That’s normally where you put a guy who can’t do much but hit. No wonder his team, the Braves, lost 100 games that year.

What’s interesting is that there is a big gap here. You have Clymer and Collins in the early days, and then no one under Cesar Tovar in 1972. To fill in the gaps, here are the least likely cyclers for all decades between Collins and Tovar (and I’ll toss in one to represent the 19th century as well). Here they are, their stats, and their overall rank out of the 294 cycles:

Name	        Year	PA	1B	2B	3B	HR	RNK
Lon Knight	1883	450	75	23	9	1	17
Ray Schalk	1922	534	95	22	3	4	12
Odell Hale	1938	559	96	32	2	8	27
Harry Craft	1940	452	74	18	5	6	68
Lee Walls	1957	402	67	10	5	6	47
Jim King	1964	478	66	15	1	18	13

There were only 23 cycles hit in the 1940s. That’s one advantage modern times has: expansion means more games.

Of course, all this talk of the least likely cycles brings up an obvious question: what are the most likely cycles ever? I’ll look at that one another time.

References & Resources
For better or for worse, I got my list of cycles from wikipedia.

Print Friendly
 Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on Twitter6Share on Google+0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone
« Previous: Fantasy confessions: I traded Jesus
Next: THT Awards »

Comments

  1. Brad Johnson said...

    I came in here looking for David Bell and was shocked to find I agreed he didn’t belong.

    What was unlikely about Bell’s was that he needed the dreaded triple to complete it. Then the impossible happened, a crazy carom off the outfield wall that scooted the ball past the outfield. Moderately speeded players like Chase Utley would have scored in the park standing, but David Bell was in full spinal decline at this point and had the mobility of…well…a Molina.

    And that was that, David Bell hit a freakin’ cycle.

  2. Neal Traven said...

    Chris, I’m shocked, shocked, that you didn’t include John Olerud on your list.

    He is, of course, one of only two people who’ve hit for the cycle in both leagues (more on that in a moment).  His first cycle, for the Mets against the Expos on September 11, 1997, included his only triple of the year.  Then again, the guy only hit 13 triples in his entire 17-year career, so that’s not really a surprise.

    Olerud’s second cycle also included his only 3B of the season, this time for the Mariners on June 16, 2001.  What makes this “American League” cycle odd—and therefore a candidate for your list—is that it was achieved against a National League club, against National League pitchers, in a National League ballpark.  That is, at San Diego, in Qualcomm (AKA Jack Murphy) Stadium.

  3. Carson said...

    I was surprised Carlos Gomez’s cycle with the Twins wasn’t included in this list.  He had such horrible plate discipline and a terrible batting average. Had power potential, but rarely hit home runs. Tons of speed for extra base hits. But was unusual for him to get that many hits in a game.

  4. Andy said...

    I remember when Daryle Ward hit for the cycle and thinking it had to be the unlikeliest cycle ever, but it looks like he wasn’t particularly close.

    Fun article.

  5. RichardInBigD said...

    You started out your artcle by misidentifying the hitter of the most recent cycle as Giants catcher Benjie Molina, when in fact he was the newly acquired RANGERS’ catcher…

  6. Chris J. said...

    Guilty as charged on the Molina team-SNAFU. 

    What makes it even worse is my finding & linknig to the game in question at the top of the article – you can tell I paid a lot of attention to that screen when linking to it.

    D’OH!

  7. kardo said...

    It is always fun to read about cycles.

    I’m just wondering if maybe it would be better to, instead of dividing by PA, divide it by Games Played, since a cycle requires all four to happen in the same game. A regular starter playing only 20 games is more likely to get a cycle then a player who never starts and pinch hits 80 games, eventhough they get the same number of PA.

  8. Didi said...

    what a fun read, thanks for the article, Chris.

    Yup, that Olerud, he’s a weirdo.
    btw, do you mean Gerut will end the season with .197 BA in the Moeller’s paragraph?

  9. Kenny said...

    Molina’s late-career triples have probably all resulted from stadium quirks. The one in Boston was incredibly fluky, and he played multiple years in the triples haven that is Pac Bell Park.

  10. Cyril Morong said...

    Chris

    As usual, great job. Fun to read. Can you figure out who was the most likely to hit for the cycle but did not?

    Cy

  11. Chris J. said...

    Cyril,

    I really don’t know who that would be.  (thinks) Actually, I have an idea how I can figure that one out.  Maybe I’ll mention it in next week’s column.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current ye@r *